Credentials Aren’t Craft

By Carol Steele  /  October 30, 2026

I began writing in February 2022 and was jubilant to immediately find a mentor, a published author on multiple fronts, willing to tuck me under her wing and guide me. It felt as though I had landed on the moon, won the lottery, and found the perfect shade of last-all-day red lipstick in one fell swoop.

We met monthly for more than a year, and her every word felt Delphic, delivered from on high, worth pondering to sort out the bits that didn’t quite land. I remained enthralled, grateful for her tutelage. I learned to predominantly use active vice passive voice and when to switch point of view, if at all. I wasn’t easy to teach. Patience is golden, they say, and she had it in spades.

She’d rearrange a sentence to make it pop and insert a word or two here and there. She’d slash a clause. Then slash a sentence. Paragraphs disappeared. Questions asking me why or when or who were lobbed my way, my mitt catching most. Those I missed sent me back to the dugout. Or back to the practice field. I listened. I rewrote extensively. Every suggestion she made regarding my story, I took. I made changes I didn’t agree with. But she was sensei, and I, the mere student, felt wholly obligated to listen and embrace the recommendations and revise.

I’d pull myself up to my desk, thrust my shoulders back, hold my head high, and wince as I cut paragraphs I felt were well written, entertaining, and moved the story forward. But who was I to disagree?

Then it happened.

I bought one of her books. As I read, I scratched my head. What is this? I bought another. Read it. Scratch, scratch, scratch.

My time with her wasn’t wasted. I learned how to self-edit and deep read. (Although every writer needs a secondary editor. More on editors in a future Dispatch.) Catching faulty tense sequences and filler words is second nature for me because she taught me not only what they are, but how to recognize them. Through hard knocks, my confidence grew. All credit to her.

After I read her writing, I was appalled I had made significant alterations to my work. But the bigger takeaway for me: Vet your mentors. In this case I should have explored her published pieces before I asked for help, but instead I mistakenly assumed credentials are craft.

Liked This Dispatch?

Get the best of Dispatches in Carol’s quarterly letters.